What Are The 5 Best Catchers Mitts For Little Leaguers?
During my Little League playing days, I spent plenty of time behind the plate.
From experience, I can tell you that having the right catcher’s glove that you feel comfortable with can make all the difference.
For parents and coaches dedicated to supporting their Little Leaguers, the catcher’s mitt isn’t just a piece of gear—it’s a critical tool that enhances performance, builds confidence, and provides essential protection.
Whether your catcher is new to the position or has some experience, selecting a mitt tailored to their needs is key to unlocking their potential. In this guide, we’ll explore the 5 Best Catchers Mitts For Little Leaguers in 2025, designed to help them develop their skills and confidently take on every pitch. Let’s get started!
This page contains affiliate links and I earn a commission if you make a purchase through one of the links, at no cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
How to Choose the Right Catcher’s Mitt for Little Leaguers
- Size Matters:
For most Little League players, look for mitts between 31 and 32.5 “. This size range provides the right balance between control and coverage.
- Break-In Time:
For younger players, a nearly game-ready mitt can help them feel more confident right away.
- Comfort and Fit:
Since they are still growing, opt for adjustable features or flexible designs that provide a snug fit.
- Durability:
Let’s face it—some kids can be hard on equipment. That mitt can take quite the workout! Look for a full-grain or top-grain leather glove that can withstand repeated use over an entire season (or more!)
1. Mizuno Prospect Series (32″) $70
PowerClose Technology: Designed to help younger players close the mitt easily, building confidence and enhancing their ability to catch the ball.
ButterSoft Palm Liner: Comfortable feel and minimizes sting from fast pitches.
Quick Break-In: Flexible leather design reduces the time needed to break in the glove.
Ergonomic Fit: Perfect for smaller hands, offering a snug yet comfortable fit.
Durability: High-quality leather construction ensures long-lasting performance.
Affordability: Great value for money compared to other youth mitts.
Product Pros
Product Cons
The Mizuno Prospect Series 32″ mitt is a perfect choice for young catchers eager to improve their skills behind the plate. Its PowerClose technology makes catching simpler, helping Little Leaguers secure the ball.
This feature is especially beneficial for beginners still learning the fundamentals of catching. Mizuno’s patented Parashock Palm Pad reduces the sting of fast throws, giving players the confidence to block and catch without hesitation.
Made with soft, durable leather, the glove requires minimal break-in time, ensuring players can use it almost immediately. The 32″ size and ergonomic design are tailored to fit smaller hands, providing a comfortable, snug feel that enhances control. The mitt also features Less 2 Lacing, which removes the last 2 lace loops on the web to increase flexibility along the closing axis.
The Mizuno Prospect Series stands out for its comfort, durability, and ease of use. Its lightweight construction helps young catchers develop proper technique without feeling overwhelmed by a heavier mitt.
Parents and coaches will appreciate this glove’s value, as it supports both skill development and player safety, making it a reliable companion for any Little Leaguer.
The Mizuno Prospect Series is an unbeatable choice for parents looking to support their child’s budding baseball career with equipment that grows with them, enhances their play, and instills a love for the game.
2. Wilson A500 Youth Mitt (32″) $70
Lightweight Design: Ideal for younger players looking for easier handling and control.
Full-Grain Leather Construction: Offers durability and flexibility.
ComfortPro Lining: Soft interior for comfort during extended use.
Flexible and Quick Break-In: Ready to use after minimal break-in time.
Small Hand Fit: Designed specifically for youth players with smaller hands.
Double Palm Construction: Added durability and support for young catchers.
Product Pros
Product Cons
The Wilson A500 Youth Mitt is crafted with the needs of young players in mind, delivering a lightweight and easy-to-use option for Little League catchers.
Its top-grain leather construction provides durability without sacrificing flexibility, making it a favorite among beginners.
The mitt’s Quick Fit system is designed for smaller hands, ensuring a secure, comfortable fit that boosts control and confidence.
One of the standout features of the A500 is its pre-broken-in design. Unlike traditional leather gloves, this mitt requires minimal effort to achieve peak performance, making it game-ready right out of the box.
The double palm construction adds extra padding, reducing hand sting from hard pitches while helping catchers handle the demands of the game.
This glove’s 32″ size is perfect for younger catchers who need a manageable mitt to improve their skills.
Its lightweight build encourages proper technique while allowing for quick reflexes during plays.
The Wilson A500 is an excellent choice for players, offering comfort, durability, and affordability in one neat package.
3. Akadema PEL998 (32″) $160
Throwback Design: Features a traditional mitt style with modern enhancements.
Pro Soft Leather: Durable and soft for easy handling and control.
Deep Pocket: Great for securing the ball and confidence during play.
Elastic Wrist Strap: Provides a customizable fit for comfort and security.
Professional-Grade Quality: Built to last, suitable for both recreational and competitive play.
Quick Break-In: Starts softening up quickly for faster playability.
Product Pros
Product Cons
The Akadema PEL998 is designed specifically for youth players, offering a professional feel in a mitt made for smaller hands.
The mitt’s lightweight feel and 32″ size make it a perfect fit for younger players honing their skills behind the plate.
The mitt also includes a “Double Flex-hinge,” which makes the glove snap closed on contact.
The glove is made with PEL leather and is designed with a tighter grain for comfort, durability, and playability.
The PEL Series is light and durable, hand-crafted with higher tensile strength to meet the demands of top-tier competitive youth players.
The material strikes an excellent balance between stiffness and flexibility, ensuring it molds to the player’s hand over time while maintaining its structure.
Its Finger Hammock technology supports proper finger placement, crucial for developing the correct catching technique.
The uniquely designed shape allows the throwing hand to access the pocket more easily, resulting in quicker glove-to-hand transfer and faster times to second base.
With its unique design and thoughtful features, the Akadema PEL998 is a game-changer for Little League catchers who want to elevate their performance.
Overall, the Akadema PEL998 is accurately described as a high-quality youth catcher’s mitt with several innovative features designed to enhance performance and comfort for young players.
4. Rawlings R9 (32.5″) $130
Pro Taper Fit: Designed for youth players with smaller hands, offering a snug, comfortable fit.
Premium Leather Shell: Durable and soft leather that requires minimal break-in.
Fast and Easy Break-In: Ready to go with a shorter break-in period.
Padded Thumb Loop: Enhanced comfort and stability for the player’s hand.
Pattern Designed for Catchers: Specifically tailored to meet the needs of young catchers.
R9 Tech: Combines lightweight feel with high-end performance for youth players.
Product Pros
Product Cons
The Rawlings R9 32.5″ mitt is a step up for Little League catchers looking for a premium option to match their growing skills.
Built with soft, durable leather, this glove offers a game-ready feel with minimal break-in required. Its snug fit and Pro-style pattern mimic professional gloves, giving young players a taste of elite-level equipment.
The mitt is indeed made with a soft, durable, all-leather shell. It requires minimal break-in, with only 20% of the break-in process left to the player.
One of the standout features of the R9 is its reinforced palm and finger padding, which reduces the sting from fast throws and foul tips.
The mitt also boasts a deep pocket, making securing pitches and preventing pop-outs easier. Its padded thumb loop adds another layer of comfort, allowing players to focus on the game without worrying about hand fatigue.
With its slightly larger size of 32.5″, the Rawlings R9 provides more coverage than other youth mitts, making it ideal for catchers ready to take their game to the next level. Its durable construction ensures it can handle the demands of a busy Little League season.
At the same time, its lightweight design keeps it manageable for young players.
Note: The mitt is designed for a high school to adult-sized hand, but it’s also commonly recommended for younger select players.
5. All-Star CM1011 $80
Pro-Level Design: Professional-level features suited for youth players.
Vented Back: Helps with ventilation, keeping hands cool during long innings.
Soft and Durable Leather: High-quality leather that holds its shape without stiffening.
Customizable Fit: Adjustable wrist strap for a secure, personalized fit.
Extra Padding: Provides extra comfort and protection for young catchers.
Deep Pocket: Ensures better ball control and security when catching high-speed pitches.
Product Pros
Product Cons
The All-Star CM1011 is a standout mitt for serious Little League catchers. It is designed for young players and has a smaller fit and lighter weight that makes it easy to handle.
This mitt features a Pro Guard Padding system that helps absorb the shock of fast pitches, ensuring the player’s hand stays comfortable during intense games.
Its Velcro wrist adjustment ensures a secure fit, allowing catchers to focus on the action rather than adjusting their gear.
The 31.5″ size offers excellent maneuverability while providing enough coverage for confident catching.
What sets the All-Star CM1011 apart is its meticulous attention to detail and player-focused design.
The glove’s lightweight build and superior padding make it a favorite for Little League players who want professional-grade features in a youth-friendly mitt.
Whether blocking pitches in the dirt or framing strikes, this glove equips young catchers with the tools they need to succeed, instilling a sense of optimism and confidence in their game.
Please Note: The All-Star CM1011 is recommended for players 13 and older, which is beyond the Little League age range.
However, the mitt’s 31.5″ size falls within the range suitable for older Little League players, making it a great transitional glove for advanced players.
Despite the age recommendation exceeding the typical Little League age, the mitt’s size and features make it a viable option for older or more skilled Little League catchers, especially those transitioning to higher levels of play.
Frequently Asked Questions
What size catcher’s mitt is best for Little League players?
A mitt in the “31–32.5″ range is typically ideal for Little League players. This size provides a balance of control and coverage suited for smaller hands and younger players.
How do I break in a new catcher’s mitt for my child?
Breaking in a mitt involves applying glove oil, playing catch, and using a mallet to soften stiff areas. Many brands, like Mizuno, also offer glove steaming services to expedite the process.
What features should I look for in a youth catcher’s mitt?
The keys are looking for a mitt with lightweight construction, a snug fit, quality padding, a deep pocket for secure catching, and durability to withstand regular use.
Does my child really need a catcher’s mitt, or will a regular glove work?
A catcher’s mitt is essential for young catchers. It provides the necessary padding and design to handle the demands of catching fast pitches and blocking balls in the dirt.
Can a youth catcher’s mitt be used for other positions?
The simple answer is no. Catcher’s mitts are position-specific and not suitable for infield or outfield play. It’s best to use a standard glove for those positions
What’s the best way to clean and maintain a catcher’s mitt?
Use a leather-safe cleaner to remove dirt and sweat, and apply glove oil regularly to keep the leather flexible. Store the mitt in a cool, dry place to prevent cracking or warping.
Conclusion
Choosing the perfect catcher’s mitt for your Little Leaguer is more than just an investment in their baseball gear; it’s an investment in their passion for the game, their safety, and their development as a player.
The five options we’ve explored today offer a range of features designed to suit young players at various stages of their Little League journey—from beginners who are just getting the hang of catching to those seasoned little athletes looking to make every catch count.
Remember, the best mitt is one that fits well, feels comfortable, and boosts your child’s confidence on the field.
Choosing the right catcher’s mitt is a game-changer for Little League players.
Each of the five mitts we’ve highlighted—Mizuno Prospect Series, Wilson A500, Akadema PEL998, Rawlings R9, and All-Star CM1011—offers unique features tailored to young athletes.
From lightweight designs to advanced padding and quick break-in times, these mitts are crafted to enhance your child’s performance and confidence behind the plate.
By investing in quality gear, you’re equipping your budding catcher with the tools they need to succeed and develop a lifelong love for baseball.
We’d love to hear from you! Which catcher’s mitt are you considering for your Little Leaguer? Or do you have a favorite that wasn’t on our list?
Leave a comment below with your thoughts or any questions you might have. Sharing insights and experiences can help other parents navigate through the plethora of options out there, ensuring every young catcher has the best possible start.
Let’s keep the conversation going and build a community where advice on finding the perfect gear can be easily shared.
5 Best Catchers Mitts For Little Leaguers (2025)
Ready to gear up for the season? Explore our top picks and find the perfect mitt for your Little League star today!
Don’t forget to check out our in-depth reviews, buying guides, and tips to help you make the best choice. Click below to shop now and get your player ready to shine behind the plate!
